Tuesday, August 29, 2023

Simon de Montfort and Parliament


HOMEWORK: Answer all the questions below on a sheet of your own paper. 



Watch the video and answer the questions.

1) What did King Henry agree to?  
2) What suspicions about King Henry are held by Simon de Montfort? 
3) What does Simon de Montfort attempt to achieve in the face of his suspicions regarding King Henry?  
4) What does de Montfort hope to accomplish by gathering the barons together in a meeting? 
5) What worries do the barons have regarding de Montfort’s leadership? 
6) Why does Gilbert The Red want de Montfort to lead? 
7) How does the Battle of Lewes end?  Who wins?
8) What purpose does Parliament serve?  
9) When does Parliament first gather together?  





The Development of Liberal Democracy Before the English Civil War

Liberal democracy rests on the principle that government is created by, derives its power from, and exists to serve the people.  In practice, today liberal democracy means a system of government characterized by limitations placed on the powers of national government by a set of written laws, legal protections based on the idea that man has rights,  the extension of rights to minority groups, the ability of the voter to select government officials by secret ballot, a lawmaking body (legislature) that conducts free and open debate on issues and passes laws by majority vote, and the ability of voters to support more than one political party.

During the Later Middle Ages, England established the foundations upon which its people would build liberal democracy.

COURT SYSTEM
King Henry II who ruled from 1154 to 1189 replaced feudal justice with royal courts, grand jury investigations, and, in some cases, jury trials.  Although Henry II’s purpose was to strengthen the power of the British crown, not to further the development of liberal democracy, his reforms developed into our modern system of trial by jury.

LEGAL LIMITS ON EXECUTIVE POWER
King John, who demanded increased funds from the feudal nobles, was accused by them of being a despot and violating their rights.  At Runnymede, outside of London, John was forced by the nobles to sign the Great Charter, or Magna Carta.  This document limited the power of the king.  Two features of the Magna Carta which did this were the requirement that the king may not imprison any free person except by the judgment of that person’s peers (equals)and in accordance with the laws, and that taxes could not be levied without the consent of the Great Council (a group of people that consisted of nobles).

Originally, Magna Carta protected nobility against tyranny imposed by the king.  In time, the charter’s protections were granted to all English people.  The Magna Carta came to mean that the monarch is not an absolute ruler and not above the law, all persons are guaranteed a trial by jury, and the Great Council, which later became Parliament, alone may levy taxes.  Magna Carta is therefore considered the cornerstone of English liberal democracy.

Below is the English translation of the clause from Magna Carta (Clause 39) that establishes the basic rights of live, liberty, property, trial by jury:

"No free man is to be detained, or imprisoned, or stripped of his possessions, or outlawed, or banished, or in any way destroyed, nor shall we go against him, nor shall we send others against him, except by the lawful judgement of his equals or by the law of the land."

DEVELOPMENT OF PARLIAMENT
Simon De Montfort's Parliament (1265) was the first instance of a parliament in which representatives from towns and the shires were summoned together to discuss matters of national concern. This Parliament is seen as the earliest forerunner of the modern Parliament because of its inclusion of both knights and burgesses, for a reason other than the granting of taxation. This broadened the types of people represented at a high level who were participating in affairs of the nation.

In 1295, King Edward I expanded the Great Council’s membership to include middle-class representatives.  His purpose was to place taxes upon and still ensure loyalty of the wealthy middle class, not to further the development of liberal democracy.   Because the enlarged Great Council served as a model for England’s future legislature (Parliament), it was called Model Parliament.  By allowing non-nobles to have membership in the Great Council, King Edward created conditions that resulted in Parliament dividing into two houses, the House of Lords and the House of Commons.

In the 14th century, Parliament forced the English monarchs to accept its legislation by threatening to withhold new laws that increased taxes.  The use of this practice was not limited to laws that dealt with taxes.  From that point forward, all laws required the consent of Parliament and the approval of the monarch.

WRITTEN LAW
By the late 13th century, English judges had established the practice of basing their decisions on similar cases decided previously (precedents). These legal precedents created a group of laws called “common law”. The common law applied to all people equally.  To protect the individual against the possibility of governmental tyranny, the common law held that life, liberty, and property could not be taken by illegal action.  In order for life, liberty, and property to be taken, government had to determine that the individual had committed a crime.  By this time, English law had developed the idea that crime was an act which violated the right of free men to life, liberty, and property.  English common law greatly influenced the American legal system.

Optional tasks for study and exam preparation:

1) Outline the entire passage.

2) Complete the following:
     - define liberal democracy, legislature, political party, grand jury, despot, jury trial, Great Council, tyranny, monarch, House of Lords, House of Commons, common law
     - List the features that characterize a liberal democracy.
     - List the rights protected and guaranteed by Clause 39 of Magna Carta.
     - What is the translated meaning of Magna Carta?
     - In the 14th century, Parliament had a means of forcing English monarchs to accept its legislation. Explain how Parliament was able to do this and how did this affect the way laws were to be passed in England.
     - How did English law define crime?
     - 

No comments:

Post a Comment